Visa and American Express Both Raised Their Dividends 16% This Year, but Only 1 of the Stocks Is Up in 2026
Visa (V) is up 22% year-to-date, while American Express (AXP) has dropped 14% — even though both companies raised their dividends by 16% this year. The split shows that a matching dividend hike did little to offset differences in operating performance.
V is outpacing the S&P 500 in 2026. The source credits two drivers: favorable regulatory developments and an asset-light business model. Those factors have kept V in favor with buyers.
AXP tells the opposite story. The company missed revenue estimates in consecutive quarters and has struggled to control expenses. Two straight top-line misses, paired with cost pressure, have outweighed the dividend increase in the stock's price action.
Mastercard (MA) is part of the same payments group, but the source provides no performance data for it, so the V-AXP comparison is the clean read here.
Interpretation: the market appears to be rewarding earnings execution and business model over capital-return headlines. A 16% dividend raise at AXP did not stop a 14% decline, which suggests investors are weighing revenue and expense trends more heavily than payout growth.